Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Please don’t. Imagine I am driving and suddenly the car in front of me fails to reauth and suddenly stops in the middle of an intersection. That would be unnecessarily unsafe.


It could just only deactivate the car if the car is stationary. Problem solved.


> It could just only deactivate the car if the car is stationary.

Right, stop once for a traffic jam, car loses sync with keyfob, and you'll become a stationary target on a highway.

Better swap out those batteries in your keyfob real quick before that 18-wheeler smashes into your car with kids in the backseat!

But hey, at least your car won't be stolen!

> Problem solved.

I guess this proves my point I was trying to make in my original post. Every xx months a sensation article like this comes out, and suddenly everyone, even on HN, becomes an expert that will 'just' solve the issue with a naive solution.

Car manufacturers, hire smart engineers. If the solution was simple, they would have fixed it already. Cars are always a trade-off between safety, security, reliability, affordability and practicality.

Great that your solution makes car theft resistant, but if also kills people, it's not such a great sell...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: