Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Not really. Back in the day you wouldn't buy a MacBook because it was powerful. Most likely it had a very shitty Intel CPU with not a lot of cores and with thermal challenges, and the reason you bought it was because macOS.


The intel laptops also grounded into the user. I still can't believe they didn't have a recall to sort that out.


Apple is extremely dumb with power management and power supply. That's because they pretended to innovate all the way back at the start and want to pretend, they still have the expertise.

But I have had 2 iMac power supply die one me, the grounding problem on a MBP and a major annoyance with power noise leaking from a Mac Mini (makes for some nasty audio output, hilarious when you consider they supposedly target creative who clearly need good audio output).

You always find people raving about Apple's engineering prowess but my experience is that it's mostly a smoke show, they make things look good, miniaturise/oversimplify beyond what is reasonable and you often end up with major hardware flaws that are just a pain to deal with.

They always managed to have good performance and a premium feeling package but I don't think their engineering tradeoffs are actually very good most of the time.

As far as I can tell, the new Mac Mini design still has grounding issues, and you will get humming issues, which is beyond stupid for a product of that caliber. At this point I don't care about having the power supply inside the dam box, just use a brick if you must to prevent that sort of problem. This is particularly infuriating since they made the iMac PSU external, which is beyond stupid for an AiO.

But common sense left Apple a long time ago and now they just chase specs benchmarks and fashionnable UIs above everything.


The tingling just lets you know you're alive.


And in many decades past, OpenStep was slowly moving its GUI from Next hardware to software sales on various UNIX platforms and Windows NT.

And this would eventually evolve into MacOS.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenStep


> very shitty Intel CPU with not a lot of cores and with thermal challenges

Very often the intel chips in macbooks were stellar, they were just seriously inhibited by Apples terrible cooling designs and so were permanently throttled.

They could never provide decent cooling for the chips coupled with their desire to make paper thin devices.


> They could never provide decent cooling for the chips coupled with their desire to make paper thin devices.

Curiously they managed to figure this out exactly when it became their silicon instead (M1 MacBook Pros were notably thicker and with more cooling capacity than the outgoing Intel ones)


I still believe they purposefully throttled the last gen of intel Macs just to make people have bad memories of them.


I presume they were just playing it safe to not let the M1 migration flop. If you're dragging your users through a big migration the last thing you need is complaints about the new hardware...


They made things even worse with fan curves tuned for silence until the CPU was practically at TjMax.


>the reason you bought it was because macOS.

That is probably the least of reasons why people buy Apple - to many it's just a status symbol, and the OS is a secondary consideration.


You have funny ideas about why people spend money on laptops.


You don't have to take my word for it, it's been talked about for many years.

https://www.google.com/search?q=apple+products+as+status+sym...


Nope, many bought it in spite of macOS because it was a durable laptop with an excellent screen, good keyboard, and (afaik still) the only trackpad that didn't suck.


I think “many” is doing a lot of heavy lifting there.


There are dozens of us!


not just mac os, also the decent keyboard and actually good display, guarenteed.


Displays only got usable after Retina. Which is still very recent.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: